• Gay BlogAds


  • Gay News Watch


  • Chris Tweets



  • « 'We are the ones we are waiting for' | Main | The experience argument »

    February 28, 2008

    HRC lays a Pink Brick

    Posted by: Chris

    Pinkbrick_09_lrg The Human Rights Campiagn is taking hits on both coasts for its decision to support Barney Frank's gay-only version of the Employment Non-Discrimination Act. In both cases, the extremism of the critics only reinforces how removed these intolerant ideological purists are from the real lives of lesbian and gay Americans.

    In New York, local politicians stayed away in droves from the annual HRC black-tie dinner, honoring a protest by transgender activists and others outside the banquet hall. In response, HRC Prez Joe Solmonese took to the podium and did what he's best at doing, lowering expectations:

    I have to ask myself: When did we all become so impatient? When did we say to ourselves, okay that civil rights thing, I'll give it a year, maybe two, then I'm done," he said. "Let me be very clear: No, we are not done. We are in the grueling, blinding middle of this fight and the middle of this fight is the hardest part.

    A year or two? ENDA came within a vote of passing the Senate in 1996. It's now more than a decade later, and it's still mired in limbo despite overwhelming public support and Democrats in control of both houses of Congress.

    In San Francisco, the local Pride group has nominated HRC for its "Pink Brink Award," an ignominious honor that according to the Bay Area Reporter is "meant to recognize groups and individuals who've run afoul of the community or pushed for antigay measures." This year's other nominees, to given you some sense of this silliness, are Fox News' Bill O'Reilly and Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.

    Keep in mind that not only does HRC support transgender workplace rights (and inclusion in the Matthew Shepard Hate Crimes Act), but also pressed with unusual vigor for House Democrats to keep "gender identity" as a part of ENDA. HRC backed Frank's gay-only version after the legendary Massachusetts Democrat concluded the votes were nowhere close to passing the trans-inclusive version. Even Tammy Baldwin, the trans activists' idol in the House, voted for Barney's gay-only version.

    Also keep in mind that after the House vote, HRC's Joe Solmonese reiterated that HRC will continue to oppose sending to the president any version of ENDA that doesn't include transgender protections. Now maybe that (ill-conceived) promise rings hollow since Solmonese had walked away from an earlier (ill-conceived) promise never to support any version of ENDA that wasn't trans-inclusive, but it hardly puts him in Ahmadinejad territory.

    But such is the arrogance of ideological purists -- whether of the Ahmadinejad variety or his San Francisco foil -- that any slight divergence from orthodoxy is heresy and equally condemnatory.

    (Joe Solmonese photo via Bay Area Reporter/Rick Gerharter)

    |

    TrackBack

    TrackBack URL for this entry:
    http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834527dd469e200e5509eaa168834

    Comments

    1. Marti Abernathey on Feb 28, 2008 5:43:53 PM:

      "Keep in mind that not only does HRC support transgender workplace rights (and inclusion in the Matthew Shepard Hate Crimes Act), but also pressed with unusual vigor for House Democrats to keep 'gender identity' as a part of ENDA. HRC backed Frank's gay-only version after the legendary Massachusetts Democrat concluded the votes were nowhere close to passing the trans-inclusive version. Even Tammy Baldwin, the trans activists' idol in the House, voted for Barney's gay-only version."

      You can't be serious. I was told by my sources on the Hill that HRC was on the hill October 4th lobbying for passage of 3685. This isn't what I'd call support. You can't equate a Congressman's vote with a GLBT organization.

      I'm not a purist, I just expect HRC to follow through with what they said they would do, a month earlier.

      Granted, I wouldn't put him on the level of Ahmadinejad, but I would but him on level with Arnold Schwarzenegger.

      Btw, nice new layout.

    1. Thomas Johnson on Feb 29, 2008 12:22:21 AM:

      Ok, I would pay to go to the ceremony where the Pink Bricks are handed out! I am certain that HRC still has plans to spend money on Workplace Trans Programs, Lobby Days, etc. HRC is only going to take the bashings for so long before they say, "F em." By the way, I was at the NYC Dinner and it was 20 people walking around with "Big hands" cut out with the middle finger sticking straight up. Oh, and it was predominately Radical Ferries....not so many Transgender folk. As I read what I just typed, I am pretty supportive of trans issues...but am also at the point where I may get on the "tranny-jacked" bus theory.

    The comments to this entry are closed.

    © Citizen Crain - All Rights Reserved | Design by E.Webscapes Design Studio | Powered by: TypePad