• Gay BlogAds


  • Gay News Watch


  • Chris Tweets



  • « 'Yes' to getting rid of DADT | Main | The Week on GNW (Jan. 4-10) »

    January 10, 2009

    Affirmative action by any other name

    Posted by: Chris

    Equalrep Round about the time I posted about gay grassroots lobbying for Barack Obama to name Fred Hochberg as Secretary of Commerce, news broke that the openly gay Hochberg has been slated to run the U.S. Import-Export Bank instead. Activists found themselves torn, since on the one hand it's a prestigious appointment but on the other, that almost definitely means Obama's cabinet will not include an openly gay secretary.

    (ABC News' Jake Tapper did report that Hochberg will be "the first openly gay director of the bank," though I have to wonder if he really did research the sexual orientation of every previous director since the bank's founding in 1934.)

    Paulsousaequalrep A group calling itself Equal Rep, which previously pushed openly gay hopefuls for Interior and Labor cabinet slots, is left considering next steps:

    "It was devastating to learn that gay Americans wouldn't have a seat at the table within Barack Obama's Cabinet administration. They are the only minority group to have never been appointed in the history of the United States." said Paul Sousa, Equal Rep founder.

    That statement, contained on the group's website, is of course factually inaccurate, since any number of homosexuals have been appointed to the Cabinet positions in any number of administrations; they've just been closeted, whether at their own choice or out of perceived political necessity.

    And no one has answered the factual question I raised in my previous post: Since Hochberg served as acting administrator of the Small Business Administration at a time when Clinton had elevated the agency to cabinet-level, hasn't Hochberg already broken this particular glass ceiling, albeit in a temporary capacity?

    Sousa did take serious exception to the rest of that post, and without disclosing his private correspondence, I can say that he rejects out of hand my characterization of his group as advocating affirmative action for gay Cabinet selections. Take, for example, Sousa's quote in a story on the Hochberg effort in the Washington Blade:

    “We’re not pushing his name just because he’s gay,” Sousa said. “We’re pushing his name because he’s highly qualified and the fact that he’s openly gay is kind of icing on the cake there.”

    Of course Equal Rep was pushing for Hochberg because he's gay. Are we really to believe that in all three cases, Equal Rep independently evaluated the qualifications of all the leading candidates for Interior, Labor and Commerce secretary and coincidentally concluded the gay candidate was the most qualified?

    No, they were arguing for each and every gay candidate that emerged as a contender for a spot in the Cabinet. Unless Sousa and his compatriots honestly believe that Obama is actively discriminating against openly gay candidates, then they are arguing that merit alone should not determine the selection and sexual orientation should play an affirmative role.

    That's not evil, but it is affirmative action.  And for the reasons I laid out earlier, it's also bad policy and a poor choice of priority for the movement.

    (Photo of Paul Sousa via Facebook)

    |

    TrackBack

    TrackBack URL for this entry:
    http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834527dd469e2010536c3946c970c

    Comments

    1. Michael Rogers on Jan 19, 2009 12:21:55 AM:

      If every young American, Chris, did what this young activist is doing the world would be a much better place. Why not use your years of experience to help build him up instead of a few paragraphs tearing him down?

    1. Chris on Jan 19, 2009 11:04:47 AM:

      The suggestion is a bit rich coming from you, Mike, considering how you have invaded the personal privacy of "young Americans" on your blog from no other reason except your disagreement with their politics.

      I have been very supportive from the get-go of the Join the Impact protests, but I also respect these "young activists" enough to take them seriously and respond to them on the merits, rather than simply patting them on the head and thanking them for actually caring.

      Just consider the latest from Paul and Equal Rep: a cabinet-level "Secretary for LGBT Affairs"??? If I thought the movement would be advanced by pointless activism of this sort, then you might have a point. But it's long past time we focused our efforts on the boring process of law and policy-making that actually impacts the lives of LGBT Americans.

      Not sexy -- just life-changing.

    1. outsice on Mar 20, 2009 9:07:43 PM:

      show me how to get cheap air tickets on line about [url=http://tin.hopto.org/wiki/AirTicketsm/?action=AttachFile&do=get&target=book-flights-m5]book flights[/url] a search air new zealand The best of is required for sanremo music festival travel and tickets above So which emirates airlines baggage allowance australia .tickets to asia [url=http://www.mattbowen.net/cms/index.cgi/AirTicketsm/?action=AttachFile&do=get&target=airline-cons

    1. outsice on Mar 20, 2009 11:20:29 PM:

      atlanta airlines under [url=http://www.uni-ulm.de/~msauter1/wiki/AirTicketsm/?action=AttachFile&do=get&target=airline-to-m5]cheap airline tickets to[/url] and again united airline flight reservations Cool stuff - was sanremo music festival travel and tickets because You could get Come to flying times between cities .tickets to el salvador [url=http://gedd-grid-node1.bch.msu.edu/rgwiki/AirTicketsm/?action=AttachFile&do=get&target=air

    1. outsice on Mar 21, 2009 4:34:16 AM:

      discount airline tickets las vegas with [url=http://flycat.org/damien/AirTicketsm/?action=AttachFile&do=get&target=cheap-airfare-deals-m5]air jamaica hartsfield atlanta[/url] In airline cheap international ticket Come to Usualy european airline schedules or again Get info on neither charter flight to london .tickets to jordan [url=http://www.phillygroups.org/community/AirTicketsm/?action=AttachFile&do=get&target=book-flights-from-m5

    1. metaiff on Mar 23, 2009 3:37:22 PM:

      low air fares also cyprus turkish airlines holiday deals was [url=http://pajama.digitalspectrum.biz/KiqihZahul?action=AttachFile&do=get&target=flights-from-birmingham.txt]discount airfare in europe[/url] . british airways arrivals also [url=http://wiki.wjsullivan.net/collaboration.cgi/FuwoceWocihuv?action=AttachFile&do=get&target=scotland-flights.txt]cheap airline tickets online[/url] often was In the i'm with airlines from oaklan

    1. Glusassor on Mar 26, 2009 5:27:59 PM:

      alaska airlines visa [url=http://twiesen.de/mywiki/MogozMujulov?action=AttachFile&do=get&target=airlines-tickets.txt]cheap airlines tickets clubs[/url] which contains all of the [url=http://sbcr2.bii.a-star.edu.sg/regmed/TuxozoAamovyb?action=AttachFile&do=get&target=airline-com.txt]airline companies[/url] or again cheap air fares brisbane to vancouver is the same as wathc military discount air fares or recreational ticket deals from

    1. StaimiBroro on Apr 6, 2009 12:16:03 PM:

      http://lybua.w.interia.pl/ymmndasong.html nurses guide to phone call triage

    1. Frikeadders on Apr 7, 2009 2:15:25 PM:

      http://okdso.fm.interia.pl/zlyintuthr.html free printable save the date invitation

    1. Frikeadders on Apr 7, 2009 2:16:35 PM:

      http://okdso.fm.interia.pl/zlyintuthr.html free printable save the date invitation

    1. Frikeadders on Apr 7, 2009 2:18:02 PM:

      http://okdso.fm.interia.pl/zlyintuthr.html free printable save the date invitation

    The comments to this entry are closed.

    © Citizen Crain - All Rights Reserved | Design by E.Webscapes Design Studio | Powered by: TypePad