• Gay BlogAds

  • Gay News Watch

  • Chris Tweets

  • « When a chaplain says 'Death to gays' | Main | Momentum for marriage and civil unions »

    February 12, 2010

    GOP's loyal opposition to DADT repeal

    Posted by: Chris

    THREE UPDATES: at the end of the post.

    Nate Silver notes that opposition among Republicans to repeal of Don't Ask Don't Tell has stiffened, even as overall public opinion remains strongly in favor of President Obama's pledge made in the State of the Union Address. His graph shows the percentage of Republicans only in favor of allowing gays to serve openly in the military.

    Fivethirtyeight poll dont ask dont tell repeal gays in the military

    Silver attributes most of the difference in the results to question wording and polling methodology, and certainly on those points we have to defer to his judgment.

    But I also bet that at least some portion of the decrease in GOP support for repealing DADT springs from nothing other than President Obama's public pledge to do away with the policy. For way too many Republicans, backing by Obama is all they need to know to join his opposition.

    UPDATE: A CBS News/New York Times survey confirms broad support for repealing DADT. The margin favoring allowing gays to serve in the military is 70% to 19%. Among that 70%, the percentage backing service by openly gay soldiers and sailors stands at 58% to 9%.

    UPDATE: Politico's Ben Smith points out that even within the CBS News/New York Times, there is substantial disparity, based in large part on whether the DADT question was asked concerning "homosexuals" or "gay men and lesbians." Not surprisingly, "gay men and lesbians" polls better, adding to the total that "strongly favor" allowing gays to serve openly:

    Cbs news new york times poll dont ask dont tell repeal 

    UPDATE: A Washington Post/ABC News poll shows even stronger support -- 75% of Americans -- for repealing Don't Ask Don't Tell. Not surprisingly, men, the elderly and conservatives are less supportive, as is knowing someone who is gay:

    The percentage of Americans who say they support gays openly serving is … far above the 44 percent who said so in May 1993. In the new poll, majorities across party lines favor such a policy, with support among Democrats (82 percent) and independents (77 percent) higher than among Republicans (64 percent).

    The poll also reveals several sharp demographic divides. Men (65 percent) and seniors (69 percent) are far less likely than are women (84 percent) and young adults (81 percent under age 30) to say that gays should be allowed to serve if they have disclosed their sexual orientation. Knowing a gay person makes a big difference: Among those who say they have a gay friend or family member, 81 percent support allowing gay people to serve openly, compared with 66 percent who say they do not know someone who is gay.



    TrackBack URL for this entry:


    1. Tim C on Feb 12, 2010 10:06:30 PM:

      These polls point out something I and many others have said: we just have to wait until more people over 60 die. For same-gender marriage, if you poll only those 40 and under, there is a clear majority in favor. Obviously, the issue of gays serving openly in the armed forces exists under the same conditions (69% of seniors opposed, 81% under 30 in favor).

    1. cheap ugg boots on Nov 22, 2010 2:57:17 AM:

      That aside, Vanderbilt has the responsibility to encourage an open exchange of ideas, YES BUT! There is "open exchange of ideas," and then there is "letting just any dumbass fool with an ancient book spout off his genocidal shit to an open audience." You may see a specific distinction between these comments and a more open "Go kill gays now" sort of statement, but I do not, and here's why: Religious extremists know how to play cute with their demented beliefs. They know how to go right up to the edge without literally transgressing the line into a direct call for violence.

    1. cheap uggs on Nov 29, 2010 2:08:39 AM:

      In re the difference between the country's elected officials' rates of favoring same-gender marriage and the public at large, as Dick Cheney observed, it's a generational thing. My guess is (and this is simply through observation) that the average age of elected officials tends to skew older than the public at large, which would then result in elected officials as a group being less favorable toward same-gender marriage than the people they represent.

    1. nfl jerseys on Jul 15, 2011 9:21:58 PM:

      data so important!

    1. Renova on Sep 28, 2011 6:47:29 AM:

      Congratulations on DADT being abolished!

    The comments to this entry are closed.

    © Citizen Crain - All Rights Reserved | Design by E.Webscapes Design Studio | Powered by: TypePad